Hamburger Menu to X
Schedule your FREE,
no-obligation case review

Shoulder Injury | $40k Settlement | La Grange

A La Grange machinery operator facing two adverse medical evaluations and complete denial of coverage secured a $40,179.86 settlement after Jack Epstein's legal team took over the case. Despite the employer blaming pre-existing conditions for the worker's rotator cuff tear, strategic evidence gathering secured full coverage for medical bills and restored financial certainty.
Imagen destacada del caso

In this case result

From Rejection to Resolution

For years, a dedicated 49-year-old machinery operator worked demanding shifts in a heavy industrial engine manufacturing facility. Performing 10 to 12 hours of manual labor per day across three heavy machines, his duties required constant turning, twisting, and repetitive handling of metal components. Over time, the continuous physical strain took a severe toll on his right shoulder and cervical spine. By late 2013, the chronic pain became unbearable, eventually requiring surgical intervention for a right rotator cuff repair followed by months of physical therapy.

When the employee sought benefits under Illinois workers’ compensation laws, his employer flatly rejected the claim. The company argued that his severe shoulder injury and neck conditions were entirely pre-existing and unrelated to his job duties. Faced with mounting medical bills and zero wage replacement, the worker was left without income or medical coverage. After his initial legal representation yielded no progress, the client transferred his case to our office in 2015, seeking decisive advocacy against a stubborn corporate defense.

Inside the Industrial Accident

The physical demands placed on the machinery operator were relentless. Over six years at the diesel engine plant, his role required lifting heavy steel components and executing hundreds of repetitive manual rotation movements every single day. This continuous mechanical force caused progressive wear and tear to his right shoulder and neck. Medical studies eventually revealed a severe rotator cuff tear, shoulder sprains, and cervical radiculitis accompanied by degenerative disk disease at C5-C6 and C6-C7.

Despite the obvious physical nature of his daily tasks, the employer’s insurance carrier launched an aggressive defense to avoid paying benefits. They hired two separate doctors to conduct Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs). Both IME physicians concluded that the worker’s conditions were solely age-related degeneration and denied any causal connection to his workplace duties. Consequently, the employer refused to pay Temporary Total Disability (TTD) benefits, denied coverage for the surgical procedure, and left thousands of dollars in medical accounts unpaid.

Obstáculos enfrentados en el reclamo

Turning Strategy Into Justice

When our firm assumed representation, our legal team immediately took control of the case before the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission (IWCC). Jack Epstein, with 30 years of experience in the Illinois legal market, personally oversaw the case strategy. Our team issued formal subpoenas to obtain complete employment records, precise job descriptions, and comprehensive medical charts detailing the progression of the injury.

Rather than accepting the insurance company’s biased IME reports, our legal team directly challenged their conclusions. We demonstrated how six years of 12-hour shifts turning metal parts created repetitive micro-trauma that directly aggravated any underlying spinal condition and caused the acute rotator cuff tear. By linking the physical mechanics of his daily tasks with the surgical findings from his shoulder operation, we effectively neutralized the insurance defense and positioned the claim for a successful resolution.

Settlement That Restored Stability

Facing a fully prepared legal team and undeniable evidence of workplace strain, the employer agreed to enter global settlement negotiations. Through persistent advocacy, our firm negotiated a comprehensive $40,179.86 settlement, forcing the employer to accept financial responsibility despite their initial denial of liability.

This resolution provided vital financial relief for the injured worker. In addition to securing cash compensation, the settlement resolved $10,591.47 in outstanding medical bills for orthopedic surgery and physical therapy, while successfully obtaining a complete waiver of the group health insurance lien. The client paid nothing until we won the case, allowing his family to move forward with financial security.

Resolución del caso

Two adverse medical opinions claimed he had no case. Strategic legal action proved them wrong and delivered real financial recovery. If your workers’ compensation claim has been denied or delayed, our Illinois legal team can help you recover what you rightfully deserve.

Our goal is to support you
We want to hear from you.

Get in touch